Shooting War Getting A Grip Wolves In Sheep's Clothing

H16858

Guerrilla Journalism Fund
Headlines : Human Rights
Summary:

As the article points out, Israeli officials quickly attempted to reinterpret Israeli Deputy Defense Minister Vilnai’s use of the word ‘Shoah’.

The argument hinges on the difference between the Hebrew words ‘Shoah’ and ‘HaShoah.’ ‘HaShoah’ literally translates to ‘The Holocaust’ (specifically referring to the atrocities committed during WWII), while ‘Shoah’ translates to ‘A Holocaust’ (or actually just ‘holocaust’, as there is no indefinite article ‘a’ in Hebrew). All in all, the difference is rather slight.

[Posted By monkeywagun]
By Donald Macintyre
Republished from The Independent
One of the most tactless statements in the history of diplomacy.

An Israeli government minister warned yesterday that increasing rocket fire from Gaza would bring Palestinians a Shoah – the Hebrew word normally used to denote the Nazi Holocaust inflicted on Jews during the Second World War.

The declaration by the Deputy Defence Minister, Matan Vilnai, came amid fresh calls from some Israeli politicians for a ground invasion of Gaza provoked by the launch of eight Soviet-designed Grad rockets into the southern city of Ashkelon during the lethal violence of the past three days.

Mr Vilnai declared: “As the rocket fire grows, and the range increases – and they haven’t yet said the last word on this – they are bringing upon themselves a greater Shoah because we will use all our strength in every way we deem appropriate, whether in air strikes or on the ground.”

Government spokesmen launched an immediate damage limitation exercise saying that Mr Vilnai was merely using the word to mean “disaster” and not in any way intending to convey the idea of genocide. But Shoah is rarely used in modern Hebrew parlance for events other than the Holocaust.

[end excerpt]
Click here to read the rest of the article
monkeywagun

Posted by monkeywagun
Paolo Unger Dvorchik is a working photographer and video based artist currently living in Boston Massachusetts. If you're interested in political performance art and video I highly suggest you check out my portfolio at www.highimpactart.org.

RECENT COMMENTS

SHIT! Someone was honest again! SPIN SPIN SPIN!

Not_Uberche @ 03/03/08 09:02:05

In the world of Israeli government logics:
Rockets fired into Israeli city = Israel is justified for killing over 100 Palestinians in “response”

EGisJUICE @ 03/03/08 10:02:28

Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livini: “The world should respect any action taken by Israel in order to defend its citizens. I would like to say that I cannot accept condolences saying that there are victims, both sides. Well yes, there are victims both sides, but there is no moral equation between these terrorists who are looking for civilians to kill and between the Israeli soldiers who are looking for the terrorists.”

monkeywagun @ 03/03/08 11:15:49
Login

Sign up for the GNN newsletter to get the first word on video premieres and breaking news. signup

Read the GNN FAQ for information about the site, forum rules and other GNN 2.0 information. faq

Optimized for FireFox
To download the Firefox web browser, visit mozilla.com Get Firefox

  • Advertise With GNN
  • SUPPORT GNN! Support GNN

    TEES/DVDS @ GNN STORE

    Buy Our Tees
  • Bloggers' Rights at EFF